Ontario Cup Final Teams

ree — Montage of the 1918 Toronto Scottish team that won the Ontario Cup.

1911 – Winners – HAMILTON WESTINGHOUSE September 3, 1911, in Hamilton Game One	Hamilton Westinghouse 3 (Wands, Houison, Tiny Thombs) Toronto Baracas 2 (Dalziel, Grant) HT: 1–2 Att: Ref: Mr. McAnnally Westinghouse: J.J. Newton – Horace Thombs, Hunter – Tommy Gardiner, Joe Newton, Gillespie – Bert Thombs, Bobby Wands, BillyWilson, George Houison, Tiny Thombs. Baracas: Hardy – Nuttcutt, Attwood – Foley, Bingham, Reeve – Gillespie, McGrath, Grant, Dalziel, Scott.
Game Two September 16, 1911, at Rosedale in Toronto	Toronto Baracas 2 (Forrest, Dalziel) Hamilton Westinghouse 3 (Houison 2, Bobby Wands) HT: 1–1 Att: Ref: Mr. Banks Baracas: Hardy – Nottcutt, Attwood – Grant, Bingham, Reeve – Gillespie, McGrath, Forrest, Dalziel, Scott. Westinghouse: J.J. Newton – Horace Thombs, Hunter – Tommy Gardiner, Joe Newton, A. Wands – Bert Thombs, Bobby Wands, George Houison, Billy Wilson, Tiny Thombs.
1912 – Winners – HAMILTON WESTINGHOUSE September 7, 1912, at Collegiate Flats in Stratford – Game One	Stratford 1 (Davey) Hamilton Westinghouse 1 (Bobby Wands) HT: 0–1 Att: Ref: Harry Brown Stratford: Preston – McIntosh, Ernie Clark – Choice, Albert Jones, Donnelly – D. Borthwick, Davey, Round, Charlie Borthwick, Jackson. Westinghouse: J.J. Newton – Horace Thombs, Hunter – Tommy Gardiner, Joe Newton, Gillespie – Gilvear, Bobby Wands, Billy Wilson, S. Wilson, George Houison.
Game Two September 14, 1912, at the Deering Grounds in Hamilton –	Hamilton Westinghouse 4 (Tiny Thombs, Billy Wilson 2, Houison) Stratford 0 HT: 2–0 Att: Ref: Norman J. Howard (Toronto) Westinghouse: J.J. Newton – Horace Thombs, Hunter – Tommy Gardiner, Joe Newton, H. Wands – Billy Wilson, Bobby Wands, Tiny Thombs, S. Wilson, George Houison. Stratford: Preston – Hamer, Ernie Clark – Dave McIntosh, Albert Jones, Donnelly – Round, Davey, Dave Borthwick, Jackson (Mayo), Charlie Borthwick.
1913 – Winners – HAMILTON LANCASHIRE October 11, 1913, at Dickson Park in Galt (Third game, first two games tied)	Hamilton Lancashire 3 (?, Harper 2) Stratford 2 (Morgan, Fountain) HT: 1–2 Att: 600 Ref: Norman J. Howard (Toronto) Lancashire: Carlton – Howarth, Jones – Ormerod, Fletcher, Quibell – Bacon, Miller, Pepper, Harper, Latham. Stratford: Preston – Harmer, Ernie Clark – Bradley, Dave McIntosh, Billie Haig – Davey, Morgan, Fountin, Jackson, Borthwick.
1914 – Winners – TORONTO EATONIAS August 22, 1914, at Varsity Stadium in Toronto	Toronto Eatonias 3 (McQueen, McNeely 2) St. Catharines Merritton 1 (A. Page, pen) HT: 2–1 Att: Ref: W.P. Murchie Eatonias: Craig – Muir, Gilchrist – McAdam, Baldwin, Abbott – McGuire, Givens, McGuire, McNeil, Patterson. Merritton: Scott – Mendock, Downes – P. Ryan, Page, McCann – Turner. A. Ryan, Clark, Hill, Gibson.
1915 – Winners – TORONTO LANCASHIRE July 22, 1915	Toronto Lancashire 3 (Thomson, Bowman 2) Ottawa Thistles 1 (Falconer) HT: 2–1 Att: 4000 Ref: Lancashire: Laycock – Arden, Hammett – Woodward, Sam Jones, Knowles – Art Jones, Thomson, Bowman, Taylor, Abrams. Thistles: Brown – McGhie, Holford – Hutchins, Tinman, Ward – Watt, Waddell, Vergetee, Falconer, Harmer.
1916 – Winners – Joint Winners Hamilton Westinghouse and Toronto Eatons Sept 30, 1916, at Varsity Stadium in Toronto	Toronto Eatons 4 Hamilton Westinghouse 1 HT: Att: Ref: Eatons: McLeary – Campbell, Buchan – Adams, Baldwin, Brookes – Anderson, Lindsay, Robertson, Martin, Harrison. Westinghouse: Crompton – McCulloch, H. Thombs – Ure, Wands, Addison – Atkinson, Howard, Howison, Wilson, Aitken.
1912 – Winners – HAMILTON WESTINGHOUSE September 7, 1912, at Collegiate Flats in Stratford – Game One	Stratford 1 (Davey) Hamilton Westinghouse 1 (Bobby Wands) HT: 0–1 Att: Ref: Harry Brown Stratford: Preston – McIntosh, Ernie Clark – Choice, Albert Jones, Donnelly – D. Borthwick, Davey, Round, Charlie Borthwick, Jackson. Westinghouse: J.J. Newton – Horace Thombs, Hunter – Tommy Gardiner, Joe Newton, Gillespie – Gilvear, Bobby Wands, Billy Wilson, S. Wilson, George Houison.
First Replay October 14, 1916, in Hamilton	Hamilton Westinghouse 4 Toronto Eatons 1 HT: Att: Ref: W.S. Murchie (Toronto) Westinghouse: Crompton – Rodgers, Barron – Ure, Wands, Willis – Ellison, Howison, Tiny Thombs, Wilson, Howard. Eatons: McLeary – Campbell, Buchan – Adams, Baldwin, Brookes – Anderson, Lindsay, Robertson, Harrison, Hamilton.
1913 – Winners – HAMILTON LANCASHIRE October 11, 1913, at Dickson Park in Galt (Third game, first two games tied)	Hamilton Lancashire 3 (?, Harper 2) Stratford 2 (Morgan, Fountain) HT: 1–2 Att: 600 Ref: Norman J. Howard (Toronto) Lancashire: Carlton – Howarth, Jones – Ormerod, Fletcher, Quibell – Bacon, Miller, Pepper, Harper, Latham. Stratford: Preston – Harmer, Ernie Clark – Bradley, Dave McIntosh, Billie Haig – Davey, Morgan, Fountin, Jackson, Borthwick.
Second Replay October 21, 1916	Toronto Eatons 1 Hamilton Westinghouse 0 HT: Att: Ref: Millsip Eatons: Adgey – Campbell, Buchan – Adams, Martin, Brookes – Anderson, Hamilton, Robertson, Lindsay, Harrison. Westinghouse: Crompton – Rodgers, Barron – Ure, Wands, Addison – Willis, Ellison, Wilson, Howison, Tiny Thombs.
Third Replay November 11, 1916 at Varsity Stadium in Toronto	Toronto Eatons 1 Hamilton Westinghouse 2 HT: Att: Ref: Eatons: Adgey – Campbell, Buchan – Adams, Martin, Brookes – Anderson, Hamilton, Robertson, Lindsay, Harrison. Westinghouse: Crompton – H. Rodgers, McCulloch – Addison, Wands, Stewart – Howison, W. Rodgers, Barnes, Atkinson, Tiny Thombs.
November – Fourth Replay Joint Champions, teams all square after five games. 1917 – No Final Played
1918 – Winners – TORONTO SCOTTISH September 28, 1918	Toronto Scottish 1 (Fidler) Davenport Albion 0 HT: 0–0 Att: Ref: Scottish: Steve Smith – Geordie Campbell, William Brownlie – Harry A’Court, Young, James – Harry Anderson, H. Fidler, Houison, Ernie Fidler, Hunter. Albion: Enfield – Robinson, Buchan – Brown, Adams, Brookes – Barron, A. Walker, McNeilly, S. Walker, Simpson.
1919 – Winners – TORONTO OLD COUNTRY August 2, 1919, at Varsity Stadium in Toronto	Toronto Old Country 4 (Aitken, Hutchinson, Bell, McKee) Hamilton Independent Labour Party 2 (Housin, Scholes) HT: 1–2 Att: 6000 Ref: O. Hill (St, Catharines) Old Country: Wilcock – Hutchinson, Colquhoun – Taylor, Anderson, McKee – Champ, Bell, Marshall, Logan, Aitken. Labour: Roberts – Rogers, McCulloch – Ure, Lawson, Tommy Gardiner – Atkinson, Fullerton, Scholes, George Houison, Tiny Thombs.
1920 – Winners – HAMILTON WESTINGHOUSE July 3, 1920, in Toronto	Toronto Willys Overland 2 (Bailey, F. Dierden) Hamilton Westinghouse 3 (Thombs 2, Pilkington) HT: Att: Ref: O. Hill (St. Catharines) Willys: Harry Stansfield – Drummond, Fred Dierden – Art Dierden, Woods, Bailey–Hunt, Herring, Lawrie, MacFarlane, Taylor. Westinghouse: Coombs – McEwan, Craig – Ure, Burns, Tommy Gardiner – Garside, Newton, Billy Gilvear, Pilkington, Tiny Thombs.
1921 – Winners – TORONTO SCOTTISH July 2, 1921, at Broadview Field in Toronto	Toronto Scottish 4 (Fidler, McDonald, Anderson 2) Hamilton Independent Labour Party 1 (Borthwick) HT: Att: Ref: Percy May (Ottawa) Scottish: Steve Smith – Geordie Campbell, Houison – Harry A’Court, Alex McCall, Johnson – Harry Anderson, Bobby Bruce, McDonald, Ernie Fidler, Teddy Young. Labour: Joe Scanlon – Burtenshaw, McCulloch – Sincliar, Bingham, Cooper – Pogson, Fullerton, Scholes, Borthwick, Bell.
1922 – Winners – TORONTO SCOTTISH October 14, 1922, in Toronto Game One	Toronto Scottish 2 (McCall, Anderson) Hamilton Independent Labour Party 0 HT: 1–0 Att: Ref: W.S. Murchie (Toronto) Scottish: Steve Smith – Geordie Campbell, Houison – Harry A’Court, Thomson, Johnson – Harry Anderson, Bobby Bruce, Alex McCall, Ernie Fidler, Teddy Young. Labour: Crompton – Roarke, McCulloch – Sinclair, Bingham, Cooper – Herbert Pogson, Duncan, Branscombe, Borthwick, Parker.
Game Two October 21, 1922, in Hamilton	Hamilton Independent Labour Party 1 (Borthwick) Toronto Scottish 1 (Fidler) HT: Att: Ref: Labour: Crompton – Roarke, McCulloch – Sinclair, Bingham, Cooper – Branscombe, Duncan, Borthwick, Herbert Pogson, Parker. Scottish: Steve Smith – Geordie Campbell, Houison – Harry A’Court, Thomson, Johnson – Harry Anderson, Bobby Bruce, Alex McCall, Ernie Fidler, Teddy Young.
1923 – Winners – GUELPH TAYLOR-FORBES October 20, 1923, in Guelph Game One	Guelph Taylor-Forbes 2 (Lee, Hilton) Brantford Massey-Harris 0 HT: Att: Ref: Guelph: Moore – Dunlop, McCall – Renton, Moreland, Collins – Halliwell, Mooney, Hilton, Kerr, Lee. Brantford: Wills – Brown, F. Gilbert – Marshall, Taylor, H. Gilbert – Plant, Porter, Drake, Mason, Harrison.
Game Two October 27, 1923, in Brantford	Brantford Massey-Harris 0 Guelph Taylor-Forbes 1 (Kerr) HT: 0–1 Att: 500 Ref: W.S. Murchie (Toronto) Brantford: Wills – Brown, F. Gilbert – Smith, Marshall, H. Gilbert – Portre, Taylor, Hingley, Drake, Moss. Guelph: Moore – Dunlop, McCall – Renton, Moreland, Cowan – Halliwell, Mooney, Hilton, Kerr, Lee.
1924 – Winners – BRANTFORD COCKSHUTTS November 1, 1924, in Timmins Game One	Timmins Wolves 0 Brantford Cockshutts 0 HT: 0–0 Att: Ref: Dolan (Sudbury) Wolves: A. Cadman – Haley, Hetherington – Cooper, F. Cadman, Shortt – Street, Christian Sathrang, Petterson, Berg, Ford. Cockshutts: Green – Dickson, Jackson – Perrin, Baxter, J. Fraser – S. Richardson, Bobby Richardson, I. Fraser, Hugh Aird, Ferguson.
Game Two November 8, 1924, in Brantford	Brantford Cockshutts 1 (Aird) Timmins Wolves 0 HT: Att: Ref: Cockshutts: Green – Dickson, Jackson – Baxter, J. Fraser, G. Richardson – Bobby Richardson, T. Fraser, Hugh Aird, Ferguson. (Only 10 names listed) Wolves: A. Cadman – Haley, Hetherington – Cooper, F. Cadman, Street – Dunn, Christian Sathrang, Petterson, Berg, Ford.
1925 – Winners – HAMILTON WESTINGHOUSE October 24, 1925, in Toronto	Hamilton Westinghouse 2 (Lawson, Borthwick) Timmins Wolves 1 (Sathrang) HT: Att: Ref: Westinghouse: Crompton – Billy Gilvear, Turnbull – Jackson, Tommy Gardiner, George – Chambers, Lawson, Middleton, Borthwick, Hamilton. Wolves: Elrick – Riddell, Hetherington – Cooper, F. Cadman, Shortt – Street, Christian Sathrang, Petterson, Roberts, A. Cadman.
1926 – Winners – TORONTO WILLYS-OVERLAND July 7, 1926, at Conboy Park in Toronto Game One	Toronto Willys Overland 2 (Woolacott, A’Court) Hamilton City 2 (Pogson, Leslie) HT: Att: Ref: Willys: Stevens – Searle, Herring – Davidson, Allan, Harry A’Court – Young, Woolacott, Berry, Moore, Ford. City: Joe Scanlon – Brady, Vickers – Cowans, Burns, Totten – McFarlane, Mathie, Herbert Pogson, Smith, Leslie.
Game Two July 14, 1926, in Hamilton	Hamilton City 1 (McFarlane) Toronto Willys Overland 2 (Berry, Young) HT: Att: Ref: City: Boles – Brady, Vickers - Cowans, Burns, Totten – McFarlane, Mathie, Herbert Pogson, Smith, Sloan. Willys: Stevens – Searle, Herring – Fred Dierden, Harland, Harry A’Court – Young, Woolacott, Berry, Moore, Coulter.
1927 – Winners – TORONTO ULSTER UNITED October 1, 1927, in Toronto	Toronto Ulster United 7 (Cowan 2, Moir 2, Galloway 2, Hagaen) Kirkland Lake 2 (Parsons, A. Hamilton) HT: Att: 2000 Ref: Ulster: Fraser – Dave Eadie, Walter Rankin – Sammy Grant, Fred Williams, Joe Clulow – Cowan, McNeil, Hagen, Jimmy Galloway, Jimmy Moir. Kirkland: Cadman – Welsby, McGregor – Simpson, J. Hamilton, D. Rhodes – D. McDonald, A. Hamilton, Parsons, J. McDonald, Pidcock.
1928 – Winners – TORONTO SCOTTISH October 20, 1928, in Hamilton Game One	Hamilton Thistles 2 (Dewar, Laurie) Toronto Scottish 1 (Anderson) HT: Att: Ref: Thistles: Mosher – T. Lodge, Houison – McLean, Crawford, R. Lodge – McDonald, Munroe, Dewar, Laurie, Leslie. Scottish: Art Halliwell – Frank Crawley, Jimmy Noke – McDonald, Muir, Condie – Harry Anderson, Grant, Simpson, Dawson, Jimmy McIntyre.
Game Two October 27, 1928, in Toronto	Toronto Scottish 4 (McIntyre 2, Warnock, Anderson) Hamilton Thistles 0 HT: Att: Ref: Scottish: Art Halliwell – Frank Crawley, Jimmy Noke – Nixon, Muir, Condie – Harry Anderson, Warnock, Simpson, Dawson, Jimmy McIntyre. Thistles: Mosher – T. Lodge, Craig – McLean, Crawford, R. Lodge – McDonald, Munroe, Dewar, Laurie, Leslie.
1929 – Winners – TORONTO ULSTER UNITED November 16, 1929, in Toronto Game One	Toronto Ulster United 3 (Galloway, Graham 2) Hamilton City 0 HT: Att: 4000 Ref: Ulster: Kirk – Dave Eadie, Dick Pryor – McCrone, Wilson, Joe Clulow – Roy Faulkner, Jimmy Galloway, George Graham, Bill Dinnie, Jimmy Moir. City: Rooke – Dewar, Craig – Park, Totten, Marshall – Ollie Sutton, McFarlane, Herbert Pogson, Smith, Ashthorpe.
Game Two November 23, 1929, in Hamilton	Hamilton City 4 (Sutton 2, Smith, Pogson) Toronto Ulster United 3 (Graham 2, Moir) City: Rooke – Dewar, Craig – Park, Totten, Marshall – Sutton, McFarlane, Pogson, Smith, Ashthorpe. Ulster: Kirk – Dave Eadie, Dick Pryor – McCrone, Wilson, Joe Clulow – Roy Faulkner, Jimmy Galloway, George Graham, Bill Dinnie, Jimmy Moir.
1930 – Winners – HAMILTON THISTLES September 27, 1930, in Toronto Game One	Toronto Scottish 3 (Somers, Cairns, Stevens) Hamilton Thistles 2 (Chambers, Tennant) HT: Att: Ref: Scottish: Art Halliwell – MacDonald, Jimmy Noke – Davey Weir, Billy Somers, Muir – Andy Spence, Johnny Cairns, Andy Stevens, Dawson, Reid. Thistles: McMurray – Lodge, Dunlop – Munro, Crawford, Marshall – Billy Tennant, McMillan, Chambers, Aird, McKeen.
Game Two October 5, 1930, in Hamilton	Hamilton Thistles 2 (McKeen, Tennant) Toronto Scottish 0 HT: Att: Ref: Thistles: McMurray – Lodge, Dunlop – Munto, Crawford, Marshall – Billy Tennant, McMillan, Chambers, Aird, McKeen. Scottish: Art Halliwell – MacDonald, Jimmy Noke – Davey Weir, Billy Somers, Muir – Andy Spence, Johnny Cairns, Andy Stevens, Dawson, Jimmy McIntyre.
1931 – Winners – TORONTO SCOTTISH (1931 finals played in 1932)
Game One June 4, 1932, at Oakwood Stadium in Toronto	Toronto Scottish 3 (Stevens 3) Windsor Chemsals 0 HT: Att: Ref: Scottish: Hugh Wallace – Billy Connor, Jimmy Noke – McDonald, Billy Somers, Davy Weir – Jimmy McIntyre, John Rossiter, Andy Stevens, Dawson, McDonald. Chemsals: Woolacott – Perry, Neilsen – McLaughlin, Williams, Raeside – Nolan, Callaghan, Newson, Bruce, Noble.
Game Two June 5, 1932, at Oakwood Stadium in Toronto	Toronto Scottish 5 (McIntyre, Stevens 4) Windsor Chemsals 3 (Callaghan 2, Bruce) HT: Att: Ref: Scottish: Hugh Wallace – Billy Connor, Billy Noke – McDonald, Billy Somers, Johnny Cairns – Jimmy McIntyre, John Rossiter, Andy Stevens, Dawson, Donald Chemsals: Woolacott – Perry, Neilsen – McLaughlin, Williams, Raeside – Ray, Callaghan, Newson, Bruce, Noble.
1932 – Winners – FALCONBRIDGE FALCONS October 29, 1932, in Sudbury Game One	Falconbridge Falcons 8 (Sathrang 4, McVie, McAllister 2, McMillan) Hamilton Dominion Glass 0 HT: Att: Ref: Falcons: Hugh Wallace – Armstrong, Airey – Aird, Davidson, Peterson – Inglis, McAllister, Christian Sathrang, McMillan, McVie. (Subs: Day, Hill) Glass: Wyatt – Scott, Jones – Holmes, Heugh, Marshall – Mckean, Fisher, Bob McDonald, Tommy McDonald, Pearman. (Skinner, Thomas,Armstrong)
Game Two November 5, 1932, in Hamilton	Hamilton Dominion Glass 1 (Bob McDonald) Falconbridge Falcons 2 (McVie, Sathrang) HT: Att: Ref: Glass: Wyatt – Scott, Jones – Holmes, Heugh, Marshall – McKean, Fisher, Bob McDonald, Tommy McDonald, Pearman. (Subs: Skinner, Thomas, Armstrong) Falcons: Hugh Wallace – Armstrong, Brown – Aird, Davidson, Petterson – Inglis, McAllister, Christian Sathrang, McMillan, McVie. (Subs: Day, Airey)
1933 – Winners – FALCONBRIDGE FALCONS October 7, 1933, in Sudbury Game One	Falconbridge Falcons 1 (Petterson) London Thistles 2 (McArthur, Pugh) HT: Att: Ref: Falcons: Hugh Wallace – Armstrong, Bruce – Aird, Brown, Craig – McAllister, Christian Sathrang, Anderson, Petterson, Inglis. (Subs: Duncan, McVie) Thistles: Francis – Meadows, French – McArthur, Sandvig, Skillen – Graham, Pugh, Wood, Swan, Emeery. (Subs: Dodds, Featherstone)
Game Two October 9, 1933, in Sudbury	Falconbridge Falcons 1 (Sathrang)London Thistles 0 HT: Att: Ref: Falcons: Hugh Wallace – Armstrong, Craig – Aird, Davidson, Bruce – McAllister, Christian Sathrang, Anderson, Petterson, McVie. (Subs: Duncan, Inglis) Thistles: Francis – Meadows, French – McArthur, Sandvig, Skillen – Graham, Pugh, Swan, Emery, Wood.
Game Three October 14, 1933, in London	Toronto Scottish 3 (Somers, Cairns, Stevens) Hamilton Thistles 2 (Chambers, Tennant) HT: Att: Ref: Scottish: Art Halliwell – MacDonald, Jimmy Noke – Davey Weir, Billy Somers, Muir – Andy Spence, Johnny Cairns, Andy Stevens, Dawson, Reid. Thistles: McMurray – Lodge, Dunlop – Munro, Crawford, Marshall – Billy Tennant, McMillan, Chambers, Aird, McKeen.
1934 – Winners – FALCONBRIDGE FALCONS October 6, 1934, in Guelph Game One	Guelph Lancashire Felt 0 Falconbridge Falcons 1 (?) HT: Att: Ref: Felt: Falcons:
Game Two October 8, 1934, in Hamilton	Falconbridge Falcons 3 (Lone, McArthur, Samson) Guelph Lancashire Felt 1 (Hilton) HT: Att: Ref: Falcons: Hugh Wallace – Christian Sathrang – Craig – Aird, Fairley, Bruce – Samson, Duncan, Anderson, McArthur, Lone. (Subs: McAllister, Maxton) Felt: Dempsey – Dunlop, Honeyman – Murpshy, G. Kerr, O’Hara – Hilton, Sweeney, Robinson, W. Kerr, Collis. (Subs: Crobie, Halliwell)
1935 – Winners – TORONTO BRITISH CONSOLS (1935 finals played in 1936)
Game One July 8, 1936, in Toronto	Toronto British Consols 2 (Bain 2) Hamilton City 2 (Smith, Connelly) HT: 2–0 Att: Ref: Don Jowett Consols: Woolacott – Petterson, Weir – Johnny Cairns, Joe Clulow, Adams – Ollie Sutton, W. Cairns, Bain, Winning, Hagen. (Packer, Clarke, McKissock) City: J. McDonald – McMillan, C. Drummond – Watson, Leitch, Paterson – T. Drummond, Bob McDonald, Connelly, A. Smith, Ashthorpe. (Subs: Barlow, McKean, McLean)
Game Two July 11, 1936, in Toronto	Toronto British Consols 6 (Bain 3, Clarke, Sutton, Hagen) Hamilton City 2 (Patterson 2) HT: 2–0 Att: Ref: Don Jowett Consols: Woolacott – Patterson, Weir – A. Cairns, Joe Clulow, Adams – Ollie Sutton, W. Cairns, Bain, Winning, Hagen. (Subs: Bailey, Clarke, McKissock) City: J. McDonald – McMillen, Leitch – Watson, Barlow, Patterson – McKean, Bob McDonald, T. Drummond, Andy Smith, Ashthorpe. (Subs: Richardson, Hughes, C. Drummond)
1936 – Winners – TORONTO BRITISH CONSOLS November 7, 1936, in London Game One	London Labatts 0 Toronto British Consols 1 (Cairns) HT: Att: Ref: Labatts: Worton – McArthur, Brown – Richardson, Connors, Aitken – Cochrane, Hamill, Poxon, Redmond, Woods. (Subs: Emory, Whitelaw, French) Consols: Dick Arends – Jordan, Weir – Petterson, Joe Clulow, Adams – Ollie Sutton, Johnny Cairns, Tommy Axe, McKissock, Garrett. (Subs: Inch, Clark, Hagen)
Game Two November 14, 1936, in Toronto	Toronto British Consols 5 (Early 3, McKissock, Garrett) London Labatts 0 HT: Att: Ref: Consols: Dick Arends – Joe Clulow, Weir – Patterson, Inch, Adams – Ollie Sutton, Johnny Cairns, Tommy Axe (Red Early), McKissock, Garrett. Subs: Clark, Hagen) Labatts: Worton – McArthur, Brown – Richardson, Connors, Aitken – Cocahrane, Hamill, Poxon, Redmond, Graham. (Subs: French, Woods, Whitelaw).
1937 – Winners – TORONTO ULSTER UNITED November 6, 1937, in Toronto Game One	Toronto Ulster United 7 (Graham 4, Aitken, Axe)London Labatts 0 HT: Att: Ref: Ulster: Harold Seymour – Doug McBride, R. McNabney – Bill Quinn, Norman Bundy, Ken Bundy – Sam McNabney, Johnny Aiken, George Graham, Tommy Axe, Bob Hume. (Subs: Singleton, Davison) Labatts: Worton – McArthur, Crosbie – Hamill, Murphy, Aitken – Graham, Kerr, Robinson, Redman, Davis. (Subs: Poxon, Hollier, Connors)
Game Two November 13, 1937, in London	London Labatts 2 (Robinson, Hollier) Toronto Ulster United 3 (Aitken 2, Graham) HT: Att: Ref: Labatts: Worton – McArthur, Crosbie – Kerr, Connors, Aiken – Collins, Hamill, Robinson, Redmond, Davies. (Subs: Poxon, Murphy, Hollier) Ulster: Harold Seymour – R. McNabney, Doug McBride – Bundy, Bill Quinn, Bob Hume – Sam McNabney, Tommy Axe, George Graham, Johnny Aiken, Davison.
1938	No competition. The Annual Meeting of the Ontario Soccer Association decided to award the trophy to the winners of the Ontario section of the Canadian Challenge Cup competition. This turned out to be Timmins Dome Mines who defeated Toronto Ulster United in the Ontario final.
1938 – Winners – TIMMINS DOME MINES July 24, 1938, in Timmins Game One	Timmins Dome Mines 2 (o.g., Whyte) Toronto Ulster United 1 (Sam McNabney) HT: 1–1 Att: Ref: Bill Rice Mines: Baxter – Barnes, Hampton – Munro, Paynter, Jimmy Lone – Willy Whyte, Fernie, Chambers, Galbraith, Henry Lone. (Subs: Foster, Jack Lone) Ulster: Harold Seymour – Davison, Doug McBride – James Loney, R. McNabney, Adams – Sam McNabney, Johnny Aiken, George Graham, Tommy Axe, Ollie Sutton. (Subs: Bob Hume, Johnny Cairns, McCullough)
Game Two July 25, 1938, in Timmins	Timmins Dome Mines 4 (Chambers 2, Fernie, Barnes pen) Toronto Ulster United 2 (Aiken, Sutton) HT: Att: Ref: Toby Boyle Mines: Baxter – Barnes, Hampton – Munro, Paynter, Jimmy Lone – Willy Whyte, Fernie, George Chambers, Galbraith, Henry Lone. (Sub: Foster) Ulster: Harold Seymour – Davison, Doug McBride – James Loney, R. McNabney, Adams – Sam McNabney, Johnny Aiken, George Graham, TommyAxe, Ollie Sutton. (Subs: Bob Hume, Johnny Cairns, McCullough)
1939 – Winners – HAMILTON CITY September 23, 1939, at Oakwood Stadium in Toronto Game One	Toronto Scottish 1 (Donald) Hamilton City 1 (Walmsley) HT: Att: Ref: Scottish: Buxton – Graham, Spicer – Gregor, McKean, E. Donald – Stan Wadlow, McLuer, Bowles, Tommy Axe, Norm Donald. (Subs: Hales, Peterson) City: Holmes – John Leitch, MacMillan – Watson, Barlow, Jimmy Leitch – Tuohey, Davidson, Walmsley, Collis, Smith. (Subs: Waas, McConnell)
Game Two October 7, 1939, at Oakwood Stadium in Toronto	Hamilton City 4 (Walmsley 2, Gibb, Gregory) Toronto Scottish 1 (Jack Paterson) HT: Att: Ref: City: Scottish:
1940 – Winners – TORONTO ENGLAND UNITED October 5, 1940	England United 6 Hamilton City 1